Are you over 18 and want to see adult content?
More Annotations
![A complete backup of pillcomparer.com](https://www.archivebay.com/archive5/images/051e78a3-ca7b-4b16-bdf3-b090acb059d5.png)
A complete backup of pillcomparer.com
Are you over 18 and want to see adult content?
![A complete backup of botanicchoice.com](https://www.archivebay.com/archive5/images/135356d1-059c-42ee-8faa-bd653048ab18.png)
A complete backup of botanicchoice.com
Are you over 18 and want to see adult content?
![A complete backup of portalknights.com](https://www.archivebay.com/archive5/images/7397dd92-26ef-49c3-a67e-45910a785c4d.png)
A complete backup of portalknights.com
Are you over 18 and want to see adult content?
![A complete backup of communityforge.net](https://www.archivebay.com/archive5/images/b95af34a-6243-420b-8316-0cd7ef173ed9.png)
A complete backup of communityforge.net
Are you over 18 and want to see adult content?
![A complete backup of marketingsweet.com.au](https://www.archivebay.com/archive5/images/b9701af1-7692-46ef-921f-6aa3f67fb444.png)
A complete backup of marketingsweet.com.au
Are you over 18 and want to see adult content?
![A complete backup of stage-entertainment.fr](https://www.archivebay.com/archive5/images/62f7856e-f51a-4bfb-959d-7b960220cd1f.png)
A complete backup of stage-entertainment.fr
Are you over 18 and want to see adult content?
Favourite Annotations
![A complete backup of casino-deutschland.host](https://www.archivebay.com/archive2/44cb92a4-fda9-43eb-9977-66f5aa4bca20.png)
A complete backup of casino-deutschland.host
Are you over 18 and want to see adult content?
![A complete backup of gerardcosmetics.com](https://www.archivebay.com/archive2/e81cf7a4-c521-46da-b8d1-3b3d8533f27d.png)
A complete backup of gerardcosmetics.com
Are you over 18 and want to see adult content?
![A complete backup of expertguides.com](https://www.archivebay.com/archive2/f432f2e3-5335-41bd-a88b-f59b7964fa7c.png)
A complete backup of expertguides.com
Are you over 18 and want to see adult content?
![A complete backup of planet-sansfil.com](https://www.archivebay.com/archive2/6b7d7395-13ed-45fe-9128-181aeae84311.png)
A complete backup of planet-sansfil.com
Are you over 18 and want to see adult content?
![A complete backup of biblemoneymatters.com](https://www.archivebay.com/archive2/839bdf1c-7293-4154-8e93-e1ed483ece54.png)
A complete backup of biblemoneymatters.com
Are you over 18 and want to see adult content?
![A complete backup of midstatemedical.org](https://www.archivebay.com/archive2/4fe75bcc-36ac-4ac8-be59-11a7908d28df.png)
A complete backup of midstatemedical.org
Are you over 18 and want to see adult content?
Text
CENTAURI DREAMS
The beauty of nearby M-dwarf stars for exoplanet research is the depth of transits. If we are fortunate enough to find a planet crossing the face of the star as seen from our observatory, the star’s small size means a larger portion of its light will be attenuated. LIGHTS OF THE NIGHTSIDE CITY On the matter of city lights as technosignatures, which we looked at on Friday, I want to follow up with Thomas Beatty’s work on the issue in the context of an assortment of nearby stars. Beatty (University of Arizona, Tucson) assumes Earth-like planets examined via direct-imaging by LUVOIR, a future space telescope A DRAKE EQUATION FOR ALIEN ARTIFACTS Jim Benford’s study of ‘lurkers’ — possibly ancient probes that may have been placed here by extraterrestrial civilizations to monitor our planet’s development — breaks into two parts. The first, published Friday, considered stars passing near our Sun in the lifetime of the Solar System. Today Dr. Benford looks at th INTERSTELLAR TRAVEL AND STELLAR EVOLUTION The stars move ever on. What seems like a fixed distance due to the limitations of our own longevity morphs over time into an evolving maze of galactic orbits as stars draw closer to and then farther away from each other. If we were truly long-lived, we might ask why anyonewould be in such
ENTER THE ‘CLARKE EXOBELT’ It’s interesting to consider, as Hector Socas-Navarro does in a new paper, the various markers a technological civilization might leave. Searching for biosignatures is one thing — we’re developing the tools to examine the atmospheres of planets around nearby stars for evidence of life — but how do we go about loo WHAT’S NEXT FOR NEW HORIZONS? The exuberance of images like the one below captures the drama of Solar System exploration. Scenes like this are emblematic of the early reconnaissance of the Solar System. We saw similar enthusiasm with missions near and far — I’m thinking back, for example, not just to Voyager, but the Viking landings on Mars, and ULTRAHIGH ACCELERATION NEUTRAL PARTICLE BEAMER: CONCEPT The advantages of neutral particle beam propulsion seem clear: Whereas a laser’s photon beams can exchange momentum with the sail, neutral particle beams transfer energy and are considerably more efficient. In fact, as we saw in the first part of this essay, that efficiency can approach 100 percent. A mission concept e M-DWARF SUPERFLARES AND HABITABILITY We could use a lot more information about flare activity on M-dwarf stars, which can impact planetary atmospheres and surfaces and thus potential habitability. Thus far much has been said on the subject, but what has been lacking are details about the kinds of flares in PROJECT ICARUS: EXTREME AEROSPACE ENGINEERING by K.F.Long, co-founder Project Icarus Kelvin Long is well known to Centauri Dreams readers. The physicist and aerospace engineer is, in addition to being one of the most energetic voices in the service of interstellar propulsion studies, the co-founder of Project Icarus, the successor to the 1970s-era Project DaedalusCENTAURI DREAMS
The beauty of nearby M-dwarf stars for exoplanet research is the depth of transits. If we are fortunate enough to find a planet crossing the face of the star as seen from our observatory, the star’s small size means a larger portion of its light will be attenuated. LIGHTS OF THE NIGHTSIDE CITY On the matter of city lights as technosignatures, which we looked at on Friday, I want to follow up with Thomas Beatty’s work on the issue in the context of an assortment of nearby stars. Beatty (University of Arizona, Tucson) assumes Earth-like planets examined via direct-imaging by LUVOIR, a future space telescope A DRAKE EQUATION FOR ALIEN ARTIFACTS Jim Benford’s study of ‘lurkers’ — possibly ancient probes that may have been placed here by extraterrestrial civilizations to monitor our planet’s development — breaks into two parts. The first, published Friday, considered stars passing near our Sun in the lifetime of the Solar System. Today Dr. Benford looks at th INTERSTELLAR TRAVEL AND STELLAR EVOLUTION The stars move ever on. What seems like a fixed distance due to the limitations of our own longevity morphs over time into an evolving maze of galactic orbits as stars draw closer to and then farther away from each other. If we were truly long-lived, we might ask why anyonewould be in such
ENTER THE ‘CLARKE EXOBELT’ It’s interesting to consider, as Hector Socas-Navarro does in a new paper, the various markers a technological civilization might leave. Searching for biosignatures is one thing — we’re developing the tools to examine the atmospheres of planets around nearby stars for evidence of life — but how do we go about loo WHAT’S NEXT FOR NEW HORIZONS? The exuberance of images like the one below captures the drama of Solar System exploration. Scenes like this are emblematic of the early reconnaissance of the Solar System. We saw similar enthusiasm with missions near and far — I’m thinking back, for example, not just to Voyager, but the Viking landings on Mars, and ULTRAHIGH ACCELERATION NEUTRAL PARTICLE BEAMER: CONCEPT The advantages of neutral particle beam propulsion seem clear: Whereas a laser’s photon beams can exchange momentum with the sail, neutral particle beams transfer energy and are considerably more efficient. In fact, as we saw in the first part of this essay, that efficiency can approach 100 percent. A mission concept e M-DWARF SUPERFLARES AND HABITABILITY We could use a lot more information about flare activity on M-dwarf stars, which can impact planetary atmospheres and surfaces and thus potential habitability. Thus far much has been said on the subject, but what has been lacking are details about the kinds of flares in PROJECT ICARUS: EXTREME AEROSPACE ENGINEERING by K.F.Long, co-founder Project Icarus Kelvin Long is well known to Centauri Dreams readers. The physicist and aerospace engineer is, in addition to being one of the most energetic voices in the service of interstellar propulsion studies, the co-founder of Project Icarus, the successor to the 1970s-era Project Daedalus A RAPIDLY GROWING CATALOG OF FAST RADIO BURSTS Hard to believe that Fast Radio Bursts (FRBs) were only discovered in 2007, as it seems we’ve been puzzled by them for a lot longer. Thus far about 140 FRBs have been detected, but now we have news that the Canadian Hydrogen Intensity Mapping Experiment (CHIME) has pulled in a total of 535 new fast radio bursts in its first year of operation between 2018 and 2019. TOI 1231B: A USEFUL TEMPERATE SUB-NEPTUNE The beauty of nearby M-dwarf stars for exoplanet research is the depth of transits. If we are fortunate enough to find a planet crossing the face of the star as seen from our observatory, the star’s small size means a larger portion of its light will be attenuated. As you would imagine, this makes planets EUROPA’S OXYGEN AND AEROBIC LIFE Few destinations in the Solar System have excited the imagination as much as Europa. Could a deep ocean beneath the ice support a biosphere utterly unlike our own? If so, we could be looking at a second emergence of life unrelated to anything on Earth, with implications for the likelihood of life throughout the cosmos. LIQUID WATER ON A FREE FLOATING PLANET’S MOON? In Centauri Dreams, Paul Gilster looks at peer-reviewed research on deep space exploration, with an eye toward interstellar possibilities.For the last twelve years, this site coordinated its efforts with the Tau Zero Foundation.It now serves as an independent forum for deep space news and ideas. In the logo above, the leftmost star is Alpha Centauri, a triple system closer than any other star 2I/BORISOV: A REMARKABLY PRISTINE INTERSTELLAR COMET The beauty of comet 2I/Borisov, the second interstellar object discovered in our Solar System, is that it looks and acts more or less like, well, an interstellar comet, without the puzzling characteristics of its predecessor, the still controversial ‘Oumuamua. 2I/Borisov’s cometary nature is clear in the latest observations from the European Southern Observatory’s Very LargeTelescope
INTERSTELLAR TRAVEL AND STELLAR EVOLUTION The stars move ever on. What seems like a fixed distance due to the limitations of our own longevity morphs over time into an evolving maze of galactic orbits as stars draw closer to and then farther away from each other. If we were truly long-lived, we might ask why anyonewould be in such
WHEN WILL WE SEE AN ICE GIANT ORBITER? With NASA announcing that its Discovery program would fund both Davinci and Veritas, two missions to Venus, it’s worth pausing to consider where we are in the realm of Solar System exploration. This is not to knock the Venus decisions; this is a targetTHE 1000 AU TARGET
One reason I wanted to run yesterday’s article about the Opher et al. paper on the heliosphere, aside from its innate scientific interest (and it is a very solid, well crafted piece of work) is to illustrate how much we still have to learn about the balloon-like bubble carved out by the solar wind. The COLLIER’S: GORGEOUS ART, BREATHTAKING IDEAS In the course of an enjoyable dinner with Douglas Yazell, Shen Ge and Al Jackson (this was in Houston at the 100 Year Starship Symposium), I learned that the Houston section of the American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics was in the process of reprinting, in its entirety, the famous Collier’s series on manned spaceflight. Yazell is editor of Horizons, the bi-monthly publication ofCULTURE AND SOCIETY
Imagining and Planning Interstellar Exploration. Culture and Society. Closing the Data GapCENTAURI DREAMS
Put a rocky, Earth-sized planet in the habitable zone of a Sun-like star, and good things should happen. At least, that seems to be the consensus, and since there are evidently billions of such planets in the galaxy, the chances for complex life seem overwhelmingly favorable. But in today’s essay, Centauri Dreams associate editorAlex Tolley
A HOLIDAY THOUGHT LOOKING AHEAD A Holiday Thought Looking Ahead. by Paul Gilster on December 25, 2020. I want to send along best wishes for the season to all of you. Centauri Dreams started as a book and became a study guide for me as I tried to keep up with ongoing developments in deep space research. But turning the site into a community, which I did in 2005 by adding ENTER THE ‘CLARKE EXOBELT’ It’s interesting to consider, as Hector Socas-Navarro does in a new paper, the various markers a technological civilization might leave. Searching for biosignatures is one thing — we’re developing the tools to examine the atmospheres of planets around nearby stars for evidence of life — but how do we go about loo FTL: THOUGHTS ON A NEW PAPER BY ERIK LENTZ FTL: Thoughts on a New Paper by Erik Lentz. by Paul Gilster on March 11, 2021. I see that Erik Lentz (Göttingen University) has just begun a personal blog, something that may begin to attract attention given that Dr. Lentz has offered up a new paper on faster than light travel. At the moment, the blog is bare-bones, listing only the paper M-DWARF SUPERFLARES AND HABITABILITY We could use a lot more information about flare activity on M-dwarf stars, which can impact planetary atmospheres and surfaces and thus potential habitability. Thus far much has been said on the subject, but what has been lacking are details about the kinds of flares in WHAT’S NEXT FOR NEW HORIZONS? The exuberance of images like the one below captures the drama of Solar System exploration. Scenes like this are emblematic of the early reconnaissance of the Solar System. We saw similar enthusiasm with missions near and far — I’m thinking back, for example, not just to Voyager, but the Viking landings on Mars, and PROJECT ICARUS: EXTREME AEROSPACE ENGINEERING by K.F.Long, co-founder Project Icarus Kelvin Long is well known to Centauri Dreams readers. The physicist and aerospace engineer is, in addition to being one of the most energetic voices in the service of interstellar propulsion studies, the co-founder of Project Icarus, the successor to the 1970s-era Project Daedalus DESTINATION MOON: A 70TH ANNIVERSARY APPRECIATIONSEE MORE ONCENTAURI-DREAMS.ORG
AN INTERESTING SETI CANDIDATE IN HERCULES A candidate signal for SETI is a welcome sign that our efforts in that direction may one day pay off. An international team of researchers has announced the detection of “a strong signal in the direction of HD164595” in a document now being circulated through contact person Alexander Panov. The detection was made w ULTRAHIGH ACCELERATION NEUTRAL PARTICLE BEAMER: CONCEPTNEUTRAL PARTICLE IN AN ATOMNEUTRAL PARTICLE IN NUCLEUSNEUTRAL PARTICLE WITH NEGLIGIBLE MASSNEUTRAL CHARGEPARTICLE BEAM GUNWHICH PARTICLE IS ELECTRICALLY NEUTRAL The advantages of neutral particle beam propulsion seem clear: Whereas a laser’s photon beams can exchange momentum with the sail, neutral particle beams transfer energy and are considerably more efficient. In fact, as we saw in the first part of this essay, that efficiency can approach 100 percent. A mission concept eCENTAURI DREAMS
Put a rocky, Earth-sized planet in the habitable zone of a Sun-like star, and good things should happen. At least, that seems to be the consensus, and since there are evidently billions of such planets in the galaxy, the chances for complex life seem overwhelmingly favorable. But in today’s essay, Centauri Dreams associate editorAlex Tolley
A HOLIDAY THOUGHT LOOKING AHEAD A Holiday Thought Looking Ahead. by Paul Gilster on December 25, 2020. I want to send along best wishes for the season to all of you. Centauri Dreams started as a book and became a study guide for me as I tried to keep up with ongoing developments in deep space research. But turning the site into a community, which I did in 2005 by adding ENTER THE ‘CLARKE EXOBELT’ It’s interesting to consider, as Hector Socas-Navarro does in a new paper, the various markers a technological civilization might leave. Searching for biosignatures is one thing — we’re developing the tools to examine the atmospheres of planets around nearby stars for evidence of life — but how do we go about loo FTL: THOUGHTS ON A NEW PAPER BY ERIK LENTZ FTL: Thoughts on a New Paper by Erik Lentz. by Paul Gilster on March 11, 2021. I see that Erik Lentz (Göttingen University) has just begun a personal blog, something that may begin to attract attention given that Dr. Lentz has offered up a new paper on faster than light travel. At the moment, the blog is bare-bones, listing only the paper M-DWARF SUPERFLARES AND HABITABILITY We could use a lot more information about flare activity on M-dwarf stars, which can impact planetary atmospheres and surfaces and thus potential habitability. Thus far much has been said on the subject, but what has been lacking are details about the kinds of flares in WHAT’S NEXT FOR NEW HORIZONS? The exuberance of images like the one below captures the drama of Solar System exploration. Scenes like this are emblematic of the early reconnaissance of the Solar System. We saw similar enthusiasm with missions near and far — I’m thinking back, for example, not just to Voyager, but the Viking landings on Mars, and PROJECT ICARUS: EXTREME AEROSPACE ENGINEERING by K.F.Long, co-founder Project Icarus Kelvin Long is well known to Centauri Dreams readers. The physicist and aerospace engineer is, in addition to being one of the most energetic voices in the service of interstellar propulsion studies, the co-founder of Project Icarus, the successor to the 1970s-era Project Daedalus DESTINATION MOON: A 70TH ANNIVERSARY APPRECIATIONSEE MORE ONCENTAURI-DREAMS.ORG
AN INTERESTING SETI CANDIDATE IN HERCULES A candidate signal for SETI is a welcome sign that our efforts in that direction may one day pay off. An international team of researchers has announced the detection of “a strong signal in the direction of HD164595” in a document now being circulated through contact person Alexander Panov. The detection was made w ULTRAHIGH ACCELERATION NEUTRAL PARTICLE BEAMER: CONCEPTNEUTRAL PARTICLE IN AN ATOMNEUTRAL PARTICLE IN NUCLEUSNEUTRAL PARTICLE WITH NEGLIGIBLE MASSNEUTRAL CHARGEPARTICLE BEAM GUNWHICH PARTICLE IS ELECTRICALLY NEUTRAL The advantages of neutral particle beam propulsion seem clear: Whereas a laser’s photon beams can exchange momentum with the sail, neutral particle beams transfer energy and are considerably more efficient. In fact, as we saw in the first part of this essay, that efficiency can approach 100 percent. A mission concept e THE OORT CLOUD AND CLOSE STELLAR ENCOUNTERS If we assume that the Oort Cloud, that enveloping shroud of comets that surrounds our Solar System and extends to 100,000 AU or beyond, is a common feature of stellar systems, then it’s conceivable that objects are interchanged between the Sun and Alpha Centauri where the two clouds approach each other. That makes fo WHEN WILL WE SEE AN ICE GIANT ORBITER? With NASA announcing that its Discovery program would fund both Davinci and Veritas, two missions to Venus, it’s worth pausing to consider where we are in the realm of Solar System exploration. This is not to knock the Venus decisions; this is a target A DRAKE EQUATION FOR ALIEN ARTIFACTS 1) For T R , choose the 300-year lifetime estimate of Shermer for the Beacon to radiate. Then T L /T R = 1,000. 2) Let’s assume that starship probes are launched from a civilization 10 ly away. (A probe such as Firefly, traveling at 0.2c and decelerating into our solar system, would take 50 A BLACK CLOUD OF COMPUTATION A Black Cloud of Computation. by Paul Gilster on February 10, 2021. Moore’s Law, first stated all the way back in 1965, came out of Gordon Moore’s observation that the number of transistors per silicon chip was doubling every year (it would later be revised to doubling every 18-24 months). While it’s been cited countless timesto explain
EXOTIC ICE ON EUROPA? The first thing to say about the image below is that it fills me with anticipation for the imagery that Europa Clipper will acquire when it travels to the Jovian moon later this decade (arrival in 2030, according to current planning). This is a Galileo image JUNO: CLOSE PASS BY GANYMEDE The Juno spacecraft swings by Ganymede today, coming within 1,038 kilometers of the largest moon of Jupiter. We have to look back over twenty years to see such a close approach to Ganymede, that one conducted by the Galileo probe in 2000. Juno seems to be one of those gifts that keeps on giving, rewarding THE ODDS ON INTELLIGENT LIFE IN THE UNIVERSE The early emergence of life on Earth is naively interpreted as meaning that if we reran the tape, life would generally reappear quickly. But if the timescale for intelligence is long, then a quick start to life is simply a necessary byproduct of our existence—not evidence for a EUROPA’S OXYGEN AND AEROBIC LIFE Fact. Europa’s surface ice is subjected to about 0.125 W/m 2 of ion radiation, radiolytically producing oxygen on the surface and a very thin atmosphere (the mechanism shown in figure 1). Figure 1. A simplified sequence for radiolytic production and destruction of water, H2O2, and molecular oxygen.CENTAURI DREAMS
Imagining and Planning Interstellar Exploration. The exoplanet watch among our readers is clearly in full operation, to judge from the number of backchannel messages I received about the latest work from HARPS (High Accuracy Radial Velocity Planet Searcher).OUTER SOLAR SYSTEM
Imagining and Planning Interstellar Exploration. Outer Solar System. Enceladus Plumes Recall Project OrionCENTAURI DREAMS
Put a rocky, Earth-sized planet in the habitable zone of a Sun-like star, and good things should happen. At least, that seems to be the consensus, and since there are evidently billions of such planets in the galaxy, the chances for complex life seem overwhelmingly favorable. But in today’s essay, Centauri Dreams associate editorAlex Tolley
A HOLIDAY THOUGHT LOOKING AHEAD A Holiday Thought Looking Ahead. by Paul Gilster on December 25, 2020. I want to send along best wishes for the season to all of you. Centauri Dreams started as a book and became a study guide for me as I tried to keep up with ongoing developments in deep space research. But turning the site into a community, which I did in 2005 by adding ENTER THE ‘CLARKE EXOBELT’ It’s interesting to consider, as Hector Socas-Navarro does in a new paper, the various markers a technological civilization might leave. Searching for biosignatures is one thing — we’re developing the tools to examine the atmospheres of planets around nearby stars for evidence of life — but how do we go about loo FTL: THOUGHTS ON A NEW PAPER BY ERIK LENTZ FTL: Thoughts on a New Paper by Erik Lentz. by Paul Gilster on March 11, 2021. I see that Erik Lentz (Göttingen University) has just begun a personal blog, something that may begin to attract attention given that Dr. Lentz has offered up a new paper on faster than light travel. At the moment, the blog is bare-bones, listing only the paper M-DWARF SUPERFLARES AND HABITABILITY We could use a lot more information about flare activity on M-dwarf stars, which can impact planetary atmospheres and surfaces and thus potential habitability. Thus far much has been said on the subject, but what has been lacking are details about the kinds of flares in WHAT’S NEXT FOR NEW HORIZONS? The exuberance of images like the one below captures the drama of Solar System exploration. Scenes like this are emblematic of the early reconnaissance of the Solar System. We saw similar enthusiasm with missions near and far — I’m thinking back, for example, not just to Voyager, but the Viking landings on Mars, and PROJECT ICARUS: EXTREME AEROSPACE ENGINEERING by K.F.Long, co-founder Project Icarus Kelvin Long is well known to Centauri Dreams readers. The physicist and aerospace engineer is, in addition to being one of the most energetic voices in the service of interstellar propulsion studies, the co-founder of Project Icarus, the successor to the 1970s-era Project Daedalus DESTINATION MOON: A 70TH ANNIVERSARY APPRECIATIONSEE MORE ONCENTAURI-DREAMS.ORG
AN INTERESTING SETI CANDIDATE IN HERCULES A candidate signal for SETI is a welcome sign that our efforts in that direction may one day pay off. An international team of researchers has announced the detection of “a strong signal in the direction of HD164595” in a document now being circulated through contact person Alexander Panov. The detection was made w ULTRAHIGH ACCELERATION NEUTRAL PARTICLE BEAMER: CONCEPTNEUTRAL PARTICLE IN AN ATOMNEUTRAL PARTICLE IN NUCLEUSNEUTRAL PARTICLE WITH NEGLIGIBLE MASSNEUTRAL CHARGEPARTICLE BEAM GUNWHICH PARTICLE IS ELECTRICALLY NEUTRAL The advantages of neutral particle beam propulsion seem clear: Whereas a laser’s photon beams can exchange momentum with the sail, neutral particle beams transfer energy and are considerably more efficient. In fact, as we saw in the first part of this essay, that efficiency can approach 100 percent. A mission concept eCENTAURI DREAMS
Put a rocky, Earth-sized planet in the habitable zone of a Sun-like star, and good things should happen. At least, that seems to be the consensus, and since there are evidently billions of such planets in the galaxy, the chances for complex life seem overwhelmingly favorable. But in today’s essay, Centauri Dreams associate editorAlex Tolley
A HOLIDAY THOUGHT LOOKING AHEAD A Holiday Thought Looking Ahead. by Paul Gilster on December 25, 2020. I want to send along best wishes for the season to all of you. Centauri Dreams started as a book and became a study guide for me as I tried to keep up with ongoing developments in deep space research. But turning the site into a community, which I did in 2005 by adding ENTER THE ‘CLARKE EXOBELT’ It’s interesting to consider, as Hector Socas-Navarro does in a new paper, the various markers a technological civilization might leave. Searching for biosignatures is one thing — we’re developing the tools to examine the atmospheres of planets around nearby stars for evidence of life — but how do we go about loo FTL: THOUGHTS ON A NEW PAPER BY ERIK LENTZ FTL: Thoughts on a New Paper by Erik Lentz. by Paul Gilster on March 11, 2021. I see that Erik Lentz (Göttingen University) has just begun a personal blog, something that may begin to attract attention given that Dr. Lentz has offered up a new paper on faster than light travel. At the moment, the blog is bare-bones, listing only the paper M-DWARF SUPERFLARES AND HABITABILITY We could use a lot more information about flare activity on M-dwarf stars, which can impact planetary atmospheres and surfaces and thus potential habitability. Thus far much has been said on the subject, but what has been lacking are details about the kinds of flares in WHAT’S NEXT FOR NEW HORIZONS? The exuberance of images like the one below captures the drama of Solar System exploration. Scenes like this are emblematic of the early reconnaissance of the Solar System. We saw similar enthusiasm with missions near and far — I’m thinking back, for example, not just to Voyager, but the Viking landings on Mars, and PROJECT ICARUS: EXTREME AEROSPACE ENGINEERING by K.F.Long, co-founder Project Icarus Kelvin Long is well known to Centauri Dreams readers. The physicist and aerospace engineer is, in addition to being one of the most energetic voices in the service of interstellar propulsion studies, the co-founder of Project Icarus, the successor to the 1970s-era Project Daedalus DESTINATION MOON: A 70TH ANNIVERSARY APPRECIATIONSEE MORE ONCENTAURI-DREAMS.ORG
AN INTERESTING SETI CANDIDATE IN HERCULES A candidate signal for SETI is a welcome sign that our efforts in that direction may one day pay off. An international team of researchers has announced the detection of “a strong signal in the direction of HD164595” in a document now being circulated through contact person Alexander Panov. The detection was made w ULTRAHIGH ACCELERATION NEUTRAL PARTICLE BEAMER: CONCEPTNEUTRAL PARTICLE IN AN ATOMNEUTRAL PARTICLE IN NUCLEUSNEUTRAL PARTICLE WITH NEGLIGIBLE MASSNEUTRAL CHARGEPARTICLE BEAM GUNWHICH PARTICLE IS ELECTRICALLY NEUTRAL The advantages of neutral particle beam propulsion seem clear: Whereas a laser’s photon beams can exchange momentum with the sail, neutral particle beams transfer energy and are considerably more efficient. In fact, as we saw in the first part of this essay, that efficiency can approach 100 percent. A mission concept e THE OORT CLOUD AND CLOSE STELLAR ENCOUNTERS If we assume that the Oort Cloud, that enveloping shroud of comets that surrounds our Solar System and extends to 100,000 AU or beyond, is a common feature of stellar systems, then it’s conceivable that objects are interchanged between the Sun and Alpha Centauri where the two clouds approach each other. That makes fo WHEN WILL WE SEE AN ICE GIANT ORBITER? With NASA announcing that its Discovery program would fund both Davinci and Veritas, two missions to Venus, it’s worth pausing to consider where we are in the realm of Solar System exploration. This is not to knock the Venus decisions; this is a target A DRAKE EQUATION FOR ALIEN ARTIFACTS 1) For T R , choose the 300-year lifetime estimate of Shermer for the Beacon to radiate. Then T L /T R = 1,000. 2) Let’s assume that starship probes are launched from a civilization 10 ly away. (A probe such as Firefly, traveling at 0.2c and decelerating into our solar system, would take 50 A BLACK CLOUD OF COMPUTATION A Black Cloud of Computation. by Paul Gilster on February 10, 2021. Moore’s Law, first stated all the way back in 1965, came out of Gordon Moore’s observation that the number of transistors per silicon chip was doubling every year (it would later be revised to doubling every 18-24 months). While it’s been cited countless timesto explain
EXOTIC ICE ON EUROPA? The first thing to say about the image below is that it fills me with anticipation for the imagery that Europa Clipper will acquire when it travels to the Jovian moon later this decade (arrival in 2030, according to current planning). This is a Galileo image JUNO: CLOSE PASS BY GANYMEDE The Juno spacecraft swings by Ganymede today, coming within 1,038 kilometers of the largest moon of Jupiter. We have to look back over twenty years to see such a close approach to Ganymede, that one conducted by the Galileo probe in 2000. Juno seems to be one of those gifts that keeps on giving, rewarding THE ODDS ON INTELLIGENT LIFE IN THE UNIVERSE The early emergence of life on Earth is naively interpreted as meaning that if we reran the tape, life would generally reappear quickly. But if the timescale for intelligence is long, then a quick start to life is simply a necessary byproduct of our existence—not evidence for a EUROPA’S OXYGEN AND AEROBIC LIFE Fact. Europa’s surface ice is subjected to about 0.125 W/m 2 of ion radiation, radiolytically producing oxygen on the surface and a very thin atmosphere (the mechanism shown in figure 1). Figure 1. A simplified sequence for radiolytic production and destruction of water, H2O2, and molecular oxygen.CENTAURI DREAMS
Imagining and Planning Interstellar Exploration. The exoplanet watch among our readers is clearly in full operation, to judge from the number of backchannel messages I received about the latest work from HARPS (High Accuracy Radial Velocity Planet Searcher).OUTER SOLAR SYSTEM
Imagining and Planning Interstellar Exploration. Outer Solar System. Enceladus Plumes Recall Project Orion≡ Menu
* Home
* About
* Administrative
* Booklist
* Breakthrough Starshot* Contact
CENTAURI DREAMS
Imagining and Planning Interstellar Exploration EXTENDING THE HUNT FOR TRANS-NEPTUNIAN OBJECTS by Paul Gilster on March 18, 2020 316 Trans-Neptunian Objects (TNOs) have turned up in a new analysis of data from the Dark Energy Survey , 139 of these being new objects that have not been previously published in the literature. With roughly 3,000 TNOs known, the catalog from this work represents a healthy 10 percent of the total, but more significantly, extends and fine-tunes our methods for tracking suchobjects.
Trans-Neptunian Objects, of which Pluto/Charon represents the best known, orbit beyond Neptune, with Kuiper Belt Objects being a sub-category existing between 30 and 55 AU from the Sun. Here the population is thought to be in the tens of thousands when restricting the definition by size to objects at least 100 kilometers across. But to these Kuiper Belt objects we can add the population of so-called Scattered Disk Objects, which exist in eccentric and inclined orbits, the more extreme of these with semi-major axes between 150 and 250 AU (and then there’s Sedna, with aphelion now estimated at more than900 AU).
Carly Howett’s excellent overview of TNOs from the Southwest Research Institute (Boulder, CO) explains their wide-range and is highly recommended. For now, let’s focus on the DES dataset and the catalog that is growing out of it. The Dark Energy Survey wasn’t created to be a hunter of minor planets but rather an attempt to map hundreds of millions of galaxies while detecting supernovae in the thousands, the idea being to find patterns of cosmic structure that may give us insights into the ‘dark energy’ that seems to be accelerating the universe’s expansion. DES is an international effort, with over 400 scientists from 25 institutions around the world using data collected by a highly sensitive 570-megapixel digital camera called DECam that is mounted on the Blanco 4-meter telescope at Cerro Tololo Inter-American Observatory in the Chilean Andes. Between 2013 and January of 2020, the collaboration carried out a wide-area survey, imaging 5000 square degrees of the southern sky in five optical filters. Out of these high precision images came the opportunity seized by the University of Pennsylvania researchers to search for new objects beyond Neptune. University of Pennsylvania graduate student Pedro Bernardinelli, lead author of the paper on this work, saw the opportunity presented by the DES dataset: > “Dedicated TNO surveys have a way of seeing the object move, and > it’s easy to track them down. One of the key things we did in this > paper was figure out a way to recover those movements .” Exactly so. What Bernardinelli and team had to construct was a methodology that could tackle deep-sky DES data and apply them to the TNO question. Unlike DES, TNO surveys generally take measurements as frequently as hourly, allowing astronomers to track object movements against the background field. Adapting DES data was a challenge. Working with the first four years of the DES images, Bernardinelli extracted an initial dataset of 7 billion ‘dots’ that represented objects detected by his software above the background levels of theimages.
IMAGE: The Blanco Telescope dome at the Cerro Tololo Inter-American Observatory in Chile, where the Dark Energy Camera used for the recently completed Dark Energy Survey was housed. Credit: Reidar Hahn,Fermilab.
The researcher was able to build a ‘transient’ list of 22 million objects by culling out stars, galaxies and supernovae; he then began looking for movement on successive nights. 400 candidates emerged out of the 22 million-object field, all of them seen over at least six nights of observation and subsequently subjected to filtering and verification. The latter involved going back to the original dataset to see if more images of the object in question could be located. Previously known TNOs were likewise useful, their location examined for 25 different nights as the researchers gathered information that helped them adjust their models. Stacking multiple images helped to confirm an object’s TNO status, while injecting fake objects into the analysis served as a check on how the methods handled them. The 316 TNOs isolated by this period of development and analysis revealed objects from 30 to 90 times Earth’s distance from the Sun. IMAGE: The location of the objects found in the first four years of DES data. The outline shows DES’s search range and the color of each dot shows how far away the object is in astronomical units. Two of the detections were more than 90 AU, or almost 13 billion kilometers away. Credit: Pedro Bernardinelli. Ahead for this team is an analysis incorporating the last two years of the DES dataset, with a lower threshold for object detection at the first filtering stage. As many as 500 new TNOs, the researchers estimate, may turn up in this work. The hope is that the programs the team has developed will now be useful when applied to other large datasets in the future. Remember that the orbits of the various categories of TNO help us to analyze as yet unseen objects beyond Pluto’s orbit that may include the hypothesized ‘Planet Nine,’ so the more TNOs, the better. The paper is Bernardinelli et al., “Trans-Neptunian Objects Found in the First Four Years of the Dark Energy Survey,” _The Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series_ Vol. 247, No. 1 (10 March 2020). Abstract.
{ 1 comment
}
AN UNUSUAL LOOK AT MERCURY by Paul Gilster on March 17, 2020 _Centauri Dreams_ rarely looks at Mercury, the operative method being generally to focus on the outer Solar System and beyond. But a new paper out of the Planetary Science Institute in Tucson (AZ) raises the eyebrows in suggesting that parts of Mercury may once have been able to shelter prebiotic chemistry and perhaps, according to the authors, even primitive life forms. Such a finding might thus extend our ideas of ‘habitable zones’ much closer to parent stars than previouslyassumed.
It seems a long shot, given surface temperatures reaching 430℃ in the daytime and -180℃ at night, but the PSI work turns up interesting possibilities in some subsurface regions of Mercury. The heart of this research is found in the datasets returned by the MESSENGER (MErcury Surface Space ENvironment GEochemistry and Ranging) spacecraft. The Mercury orbiter identified numerous volatile-bearing surfaces on Mercury, with high abundances of sulfur, chlorine and potassium, and polar ice in permanently shadowed craters at theplanet’s poles.
Key to the research are Mercury’s ‘chaotic’ terrains, hilly and fractured areas first seen in 1974 in the flybys of Mariner 10. The planet’s spectacular Caloris Basin is a crater about 1525 kilometers across ringed by mile-high mountains. Interestingly, numerous chaotic terrains are found directly on the other side of the planet from the Caloris Basin, leading to the theory that the impact produced them. The new paper finds that idea unconvincing. Instead, the chaotic terrains seem to have formed through gradual developments of a non-catastrophic nature. From the paper: > We attribute the immense volume losses, which we infer to have > occurred during chaotic terrain formation… to widespread collapse > associated with the devolatilization of hundreds of meters to a few > kilometers of upper crustal materials. In the context of this > hypothesis, we define “collapse” as encompassing elevation > losses due to (1) mass wasting associated with the sublimation of > surface/near-surface volatiles and (2) gravity-driven terrain > disintegration over zones of deep volatile evacuation. IMAGE: Extent of a vast chaotic terrain (white outline) at the antipode of the Caloris basin (~5 x 105 km2). Credit: Rodriguez et al. In other words, no impact needed. The authors note that the chaotic terrain is not geographically limited to the Caloris antipode, suggesting that the volatile-rich crust may have been global. They also find that the antipodal area experienced an active phase about 1.8 billion years ago for reasons unknown. The paper identifies large areas of surface elevation losses within the antipodal chaotic terrains, a finding the authors interpret as the result of crustal volatiles turning into gas and escaping from Mercury’s upper crust over an area of about 500,000 square kilometers. Daniel Berman (Planetary Science Institute) is a co-author of thepaper:
> “The deep valleys and enormous mountains that now characterize the > chaotic terrains were once part of volatile-rich geologic deposits a > few kilometers deep, and do not consist of ancient cratered surfaces > that were seismically disturbed due to the formation of Mercury’s > Caloris impact basin on the opposite side of the planet, as some > scientists had speculated. A key to the discovery was the finding > that the development of the chaotic terrains persisted until > approximately 1.8 billion years ago, 2 billion years after the > Caloris basin formed.” IMAGE: Zoom in showing variable magnitudes of collapse, which includes a relatively unmodified rim section that is smooth but not broken into knobs (arrow 1). This area adjoins another part of the rim that has been almost entirely removed (arrow 2). The adjacent intercrater regions also exhibit deep and abrupt relief losses (arrows 3 & 4). Credit: Rodriguez et al. Where did this volatile-rich crust come from? One possibility is impacts from outer Solar System objects or perhaps main belt asteroids. Another is outgassing of volatiles from the interior. PSI’s Jeff Kargel, likewise a co-author, makes this interestingpoint:
> “We also observe evidence of surficial devolatilization, probably > caused by solar heating. If so, we have an opportunity to infer the > range of Mercury’s volatile properties and compositions… While > not all volatiles make for habitability, water ice can if > temperatures are right. Some of Mercury’s other volatiles may have > added to the characteristics of a former aqueous niche. Even if > habitable conditions existed only briefly, relics of prebiotic > chemistry or rudimentary life still might exist in the chaotic> terrains.”
IMAGE: Context view showing the location and extent of the chaotic terrain antipodal to the Caloris basin (outlined in white) relative to the ray systems of the Kuiper and Debussy impact craters. (B) Close-up view of panel A that provides the context and locations for panels C and D. The numbers 1-9 identify individual rays within the region’s view. (C, D) Close-up view showing crater rays that extend over the chaotic terrain (green lines 6, 8, 9) and other crater rays that appear truncated over the chaotic terrain (red lines 1-5, 7). We provide the location of the hollow hosting crater Dario in panel C. Credit: Rodriguez et al. That volatile losses may not all be ancient is inferred from the fact that crater ejecta rays are not found in extensive areas of the chaotic terrain, which the authors interpret as indicating more recent activity. Mercury’s ‘hollows’ — small depressions resembling melt pits in terrestrial permafrost — have likewise been investigated as signs of near-surface volatile losses, although the matter is still under investigation. Whatever the case, it’s apparent that MESSENGER has returned enough information to offer up a first round of potential landing sites to investigate the planet’s volatile-rich crust and conceivably study its unexplored potential forastrobiology.
The paper is Rodriguez et al., “The Chaotic Terrains of Mercury Reveal a History of Planetary Volatile Retention and Loss in the Innermost Solar System,” _Scientific Reports_ 10, Article number: 4737 (2020). Full text.
{ 9 comments
}
EXOPLANET CLIMATOLOGY: SURPRISING FIND FROM ESPRESSO by Paul Gilster on March 16, 2020 Learning about the climate on exoplanets is not something that the designers of ESPRESSO had in mind. Installed at the European Southern Observatory’s Very Large Telescope at Paranal (Chile), the Echelle SPectrograph for Rocky Exoplanet and Stable Spectroscopic Observations combines the light of the four VLT telescopes, making it a powerful instrument indeed. We have what is in effect a 16-meter telescope that really ramps up the capability of radial velocity methods. But climate? The case in point is WASP-76b, some 390 light years away in Pisces. So much of the excitement surrounding ESPRESSO has been its ability to drill down to detect small, rocky exoplanets, but this world is somewhere near Jupiter mass, considerably larger in radius, and hellishly close to its star, an F7-class object about 1.5 times as massive as the Sun. The planet orbits the star every 1.8 days at an orbital distance of 0.03 AU and appears to be tidally locked. The result: Temperatures in the area of 2,400° C, breaking molecules apart and causing metals to evaporate. Throw in a dark-side temperature of about 1,500° C and you’ve got an incubator for extreme winds carrying iron vapor into the nightside, where it precipitates as what we might call an iron rain. This is more than conjecture, as ESPRESSO is powerful enough to detect a strong iron vapor signature at the edge of this planet’s ‘evening,’ with no such signature on the other side. Says Christope Lovis (University of Geneva): > “Surprisingly… we don’t see iron vapour on the other side of > the planet, in the morning. The conclusion is that the iron has > condensed during the night. In other words, it rains iron on the > night side of this extreme exoplanet.” IMAGE: WASP-76b’s showers appear to consist of iron raindrops, as seen in this illustration. Credit: M. Kornmesser/ESO. ESPRESSO is just coming into its own. First light occurred in 2017, and the WASP-76b work draws on the first scientific observations made with the instrument in September of 2018. We’re beginning to see that this spectrograph has unusual potential, as principal investigator Francesco Pepe notes: > “We thought very early on that we could use the instrument not > only to discover new planets, but also to characterize those that > are already known. However, until 2018, we didn’t realise how > powerful ESPRESSO really was in this field.” Climatology on extreme planets makes that case, and we can assume WASP-76b is only the first such investigation. Meanwhile, we continue to witness the ever increasing power of radial velocity methods, which measure tiny variations in the Doppler signature of stars as they are pulled back and forth by the planetary systems around them. Transiting worlds have been of crucial assistance as we have built up the exoplanet catalog, but radial velocity can measure planets that do not cross the face of their star as seen from Earth. Moving beyond detection levels of 1 meter per second, the new goal is 10 centimeters per second and below, a radial velocity precision sufficient to detect an Earth-mass planet in the habitable zone of a small star. The paper is Ehrenreich et al., “Nightside condensation of iron in an ultrahot giant exoplanet,” published online by _Nature_ 11 March2020 (abstract ).
And we should note this, from the journal: “This is an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication. _Nature Research_ are providing this early version of the manuscript as a service to our customers. The manuscript will undergo copyediting, typesetting and a proof review before it is published in its final form. Please note that during the production process errors may be discovered which could affect the content, and all legal disclaimers apply.” In the era of easily available preprints, we always have to keep in mind the consequences of authorial and editorial changes later in the process. These can sometimes be significant.{ 9 comments
}
A RARE BROWN DWARF ECLIPSING BINARY by Paul Gilster on March 11, 2020 The SPECULOOS-South Observatory at Cerro Paranal, Chile houses four 1-meter robotic telescopes, now deployed in the service of identifying rocky planets transiting low-mass stars and brown dwarfs. Acronym untanglement: SPECULOOS stands for Search for habitable Planets EClipsing ULtra-cOOl Stars. An early success here is the just reported discovery of a triple brown dwarf system, with an inner binary that is eclipsing and a widely separated brown dwarf companion. The inner binary is what is known as a _double-lined_ system, meaning that spectral lines from both eclipsing stars are visible in the data. Data from the W. M. Keck Observatoy (Maunakea) and the 8-meter Very Large Telescope (VLT), each equipped with sensitive spectrometers, were used to confirm the discovery. Yesterday we saw how the analysis of a young exoplanet, DS Tuc Ab, could offer insights into how ‘hot Neptunes’ form. In a similar way, the brown dwarf triple system 2M1510A fills a needed gap in our data. A member of a 45 million year old moving group, the age of the system matches up with some currently imaged exoplanets, so we have another look at evolutionary models, this time of brown dwarfs, that may also be useful in the study ofyoung planets.
This is also a rare find, as there is only one double-line eclipsing brown dwarf binary known — I’ll mercifully shorten its name to 2M0535 — but it’s so young (part of the 1 million year old Orion Nebular Cluster) that it’s difficult to work into current evolutionary models. The new triple system 2M1510, in which we can identify the mass and radius of the inner binary stars, will be a useful tool. As the authors of the paper on this work note: “The system’s age matches those of currently known directly imaged exoplanets so 2M1510A provides an opportunity to benchmark evolutionary models of brown dwarfs and young planets.” Amaury Triaud (University of Birmingham, UK) is lead author of the study, which has just appeared in _Nature Astronomy_: > “Collecting a combination of mass, radius, and age is really rare > for a star, let alone for a brown dwarf. Usually one or more of > these measurements is missing. By drawing all these elements > together, we were able to verify theoretical models for how brown > dwarfs cool, models which are over 30 years old. We found the models > match remarkably well with the observations, a testament to human> ingenuity.”
IMAGE: This illustration shows the average brown dwarf is much smaller than our sun and low mass stars and only slightly larger than the planet Jupiter. Credit: NASA Goddard Space Flight Center. I was startled to find that six other brown dwarf triple systems have been identified, but 2M1510 is the only one with three components that are of approximately the same mass, Moreover, the separation ratio between the inner and outer orbits is the smallest of all the young triple brown dwarf systems yet found. As so-called ‘failed stars,’ brown dwarfs are in the murky region between star and giant planet, unable to sustain hydrogen fusion, but as far as we know forming like stars. We can consider them a key link between star and planetformation.
Brown dwarfs cool as they age, which reduces their radius as well as their luminosity. Young exoplanets do the same, making the two evolutionary models interesting to compare. That makes systems where we can get accurate mass, radius and age determinations crucial, which is why this is a helpful discovery. The authors explain what 2M1510has revealed:
> We find that widely used evolutionary models do reproduce the mass, > radius and age of the binary components remarkably well, but > overestimate their luminosity by up to 0.65 magnitudes, which could > result in underestimations of 20% to 35% of photometric masses for > directly imaged exoplanets and young-field brown dwarfs. I suppose nothing elevated interest in planets around low-mass stars more than the seven small worlds around the TRAPPIST-1 system, in which the primary is an ultra-cool red dwarf star. Close-in rocky worlds around brown dwarfs are likewise a possibility, given that we’ve already identified planets at the brown dwarfs 2M1207, 2MASS J044144, and MOA-2007-BLG-192L, with the latter being roughly 3.3 Earth masses (this one was detected by gravitational microlensing, and is the smallest exoplanet I know of around a brown dwarf). But as we’re seeing, the usefulness of brown dwarfs in planet formation models is another reason that interest in these dim objects isintensifying.
The paper is Triaud et al., “An eclipsing substellar binary in a young triple system discovered by SPECULOOS,” _Nature Astronomy_ 9 March 2020 (abstract).
{ 6 comments
}
WHERE DO ‘HOT NEPTUNES’ COME FROM? by Paul Gilster on March 10, 2020 Learning about the orbital tilt of a distant exoplanet may help us understand how young planets evolve, and especially how they interact with both their star and other nearby planets. Thus the question of ‘hot Neptunes’ and the mechanisms that put them in place.The issue has been under study since 2004. Are we looking at planets laden with frozen ices that have somehow migrated to the inner system, or are these worlds that formed in place, so that their heavy elements are highly refractory materials that can withstand high disk temperatures? Among the exoplanets that can give us guidance here is DS Tuc Ab, discovered in 2019 in data from the TESS mission (Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite). Here we have a young world whose host is conveniently part of the 45 million year old Tucana-Horologium moving group (allowing us to establish its age), a planet within a binary system in the constellation Tucana. The binary stars are a G-class and K-class star, with DS Tuc Ab orbiting the G-class primary. A team at the Center for Astrophysics | Harvard & Smithsonian has developed a new modeling tool that is described in a paper to be published in _The Astrophysical Journal Letters_, one that allows them to measure the orbital tilt of DS Tuc Ab, the first time the tilt of a planet this young has been determined. Systems evolve over billions of years, making analysis of the formation and orbital configuration of their planets difficult. It’s clear from the team’s work that DS Tuc Ab did not, in the words of the CfA’s George Zhou, “get flung into its star system. That opens up many other possibilities for other, similar young exoplanets…” The work was complicated by the fact that the host star, DS Tuc A, was covered up to 40% in star spots. David Latham (CfA) describes thesituation:
> “We had to infer how many spots there were, their size, and their > color. Each time we’d add a star spot, we’d check its > consistency with everything we already knew about the planet. As > TESS finds more young stars like DS Tuc A, where the shadow of a > transiting planet is hidden by variations due to star spots, this > new technique for uncovering the signal of the planet will lead to a > better understanding of the early history of planets in their> infancy.”
The work proceeded using the Planet Finder Spectrograph on the Magellan Clay Telescope at Las Campanas Observatory in Chile, with the goal of finding out whether this newly formed world had experienced chaotic interactions in its past that could account for its current orbital position. The analysis involved modeling how the planet blocked light across the surface of the star, folding in the team’s projections of how the star spots changed the stellar light emitted. A well-aligned orbit would block an equal amount of light as the planet passed across the star’s surface. The method should aid the study of other young ‘hot Neptunes.’ IMAGE: Animation courtesy of George Zhou, CfA. Top right illustration of DS Tuc AB by M Weiss, CfA. Benjamin Montet (University of New South Wales) is lead author of a companion paper on which the CfA team were co-authors (citation below). Montet’s team used a different technique called the Rossiter-McLauglin effect to study the planet. Here the researchers measure slight blueshifts and redshifts in the star’s spectrum while simultaneously modeling both transit and stellar activity signals.Says Montet;
> “DS Tuc Ab is at an interesting age. We can see the planet, but we > thought it was still too young for the orbit of other distant stars > to manipulate its path.” What the combined work suggests is that DS Tuc Ab, because of its youth, probably did not form further out and migrate in. Its flat orbital tilt also indicates that the second star in the binary did not produce interactions that pulled it into its current position. The authors of the Montet paper consider this work “a first data point” in an analysis that may eventually confirm or rule out the hypothesis that wide binary companions can tilt protoplanetary disks to produce high inclination orbits in the planets that form withinthem.
A good deal of work is ahead to understand such young systems, but the methods the Montet team used are promising, for the Rossier-McLaughlin (R-M) effect proves to be potent. From the already published companionpaper:
> DS Tuc Ab is one of a small number of planets to be confirmed by a > detection of its R-M signal rather than its spectroscopic orbit. > This approach may be the optimal strategy for future confirmation of > young planets orbiting rapidly-rotating stars. While the RV of the star varies on rotational period timescales at the > 300 m s−1 level, it does so relatively smoothly over transit > timescales, enabling us to cleanly disentangle the stellar and > planetary signals. While this planet would require a dedicated > series of many spectra and a detailed data-driven analysis to > measure a spectroscopic orbit, the R-M signal is visible by eye in > observations from a single night. For certain systems, in addition > to a more amenable noise profile, the amplitude of the R-M signal > can be larger than the Doppler amplitude. Similar observations to > these should be achievable for more young planets as they are > discovered, which will shed light onto the end states of planet > formation in protoplanetary disks. So now we’re seeing two complementary methods for studying young planetary systems, both of which have turned in useful data on how one ‘hot Neptune’ must have formed. Results of the CfA study will be published in _The Astrophysical Journal Letters_. The companion study is Montet et al., “The Young Planet DS Tuc Ab Has a Low Obliquity,” _The Astronomical Journal_ Vol. 159, No. 3 (20 February 2020). Abstract/
Preprint .
{ 3 comments
}
WFIRST: READY FOR CONSTRUCTION by Paul Gilster on March 9, 2020 With the James Webb Space Telescope now declared ‘a fully assembled observatory’ by NASA, environmental tests loom for the instrument, which is now slated for launch in March of 2021. Within that context, we need to place WFIRST (Wide-Field Infrared Space Telescope), whose development was delayed for several years because of cost overruns on JWST. Recall that WFIRST was the top priority for a flagship mission in the last astrophysics DecadalSurvey.
The good news is that NASA has just announced that WFIRST has passed what it is calling ‘a critical programmatic and technical milestone,’ which opens the path to hardware development and testing. With a viewing area 100 times larger than the Hubble instrument, WFIRST will be able to investigate dark energy and dark matter while at the same time examining exoplanets by using microlensing techniques applied to the inner Milky Way. Its exoplanet capabilities could be significantly extended if additional budgeting for a coronagraph — which would allow direct imaging of exoplanets — winds up being approved. And that is a big ‘if.’ No one doubts the power of a coronagraph onboard WFIRST to block the light of a central star in order to examine any planets found around it, but this telescope has already suffered considerable budget anxiety, leading NASA to separate the coronagraph, now described as a ‘technology demonstration,’ from the $3.2 billion budget estimate. Adding the coronagraph and subsequent operations would take the total WFIRST tally to $3.9billion.
IMAGE: This graphic shows a simulation of a WFIRST observation of M31, also known as the Andromeda galaxy. Hubble used more than 650 hours to image areas outlined in blue. Using WFIRST, covering the entire galaxy would take only three hours. Credits: DSS, R. Gendle, NASA, GSFC, ASU, STScI, B. F. Williams. Will Congress approve funding for the coronagraph, or will WFIRST fly without it? Will WFIRST fly at all, given that Congress has already had to save the telescope twice from cancellation? The current FY2021 budget request proposes terminating the telescope, but it continues to receive congressional support and remains on schedule for a 2025 launch. It should be noted that a coronagraph was not part of the Decadal Survey’s recommendations, which factors into the discussion and may put pressure on those hoping to raise the needed additionalfunding.
Note this from NASA’s March 2 statement: > The FY2020 Consolidated Appropriations Act funds the WFIRST program > through September 2020. The FY2021 budget request proposes to > terminate funding for the WFIRST mission and focus on the completion > of the James Webb Space Telescope, now planned for launch in March > 2021. The Administration is not ready to proceed with another > multi-billion-dollar telescope until Webb has been successfully > launched and deployed. The expectation is that Congress will keep WFIRST in the budget but the corongraph remains an open question. So the first priority is keeping the mission alive, while it’s clear that the cost overruns that have so exasperated astronomers and politicians alike with the James Webb instrument have played a role in keeping the brakes on WFIRST spending. As we saw recently in these pages, the Decadal Surveys (from the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine) set science priorities for NASA and other science agencies. The lack of a coronagraph within the last astrophysics Decadal Survey doesn’t help its chances now.{ 15 comments
}
COSMIC EXPANSION: A CLOSE LOOK AT A ‘STANDARD CANDLE’ by Paul Gilster on March 6, 2020 Astronomy relies on so-called ‘standard candles’ to make crucial measurements about distance. Cepheid variables, for example, perhaps the most famous stars in this category, were examined by Henrietta Swan Leavitt in 1908 as part of her study of variable stars in the Magellanic clouds, revealing the relationship between this type of star’s period and luminosity. Edwin Hubble would use distance calculations based on this relationship to estimate how far what was then called the ‘Andromeda Nebula’ was from our galaxy, revealing the true nature of the ‘nebula.’ In recent times, astronomers have used type Ia supernovae in much the same way, for comparing a source’s intrinsic brightness with what is observed in the sky likewise determines distance. The most commonly described type Ia supernovae model occurs in binary systems where one of the stars is a white dwarf, and the assumption among astronomers has been that this category of supernova produces a consistent peak luminosity that can be used to measure interstellar, and intergalactic, distances. It was through the study of type Ia supernovae that the idea of dark energy arose to explain the apparent acceleration of the universe’s expansion, but we can also point to our methods for measuring the Hubble constant, which helps us gauge the current expansion rate ofthe cosmos.
Given the importance of standard candles to astronomy, we have to get them right. Now we have new work out of the Max Planck Institute for Astronomy in Heidelberg. A team led by Maria Bergemann draws our assumptions about these supernovae into question, and that could cause a reassessment of the rate of cosmic expansion. At issue: Are all type 1a supernovae the same? Bergemann’s work on stellar atmospheres has, since 2005, focused on new models to examine the spectral lines observed there, the crucial measurements that lead to data on a star’s temperature, surface pressure and chemical composition. Computer simulations of convection within a star and the interactions of plasma with the star’s radiation have been producing and reinforcing so-called Non-LTE models that assume no local thermal equilibrium, leading to new ways to explore chemical abundances that alter our previous findings on someelements.
The team at MPIA has zeroed in on the element manganese using observational data in the near-ultraviolet, and extending the analysis beyond single stars to work with the combined light of numerous stars in a stellar cluster, which allows the examination of other galaxies. It takes a supernova explosion to produce manganese, and different types of supernova produce iron and manganese in different ratios. Thus a massive star going supernova, a ‘core collapse supernova,’ produces manganese and iron differently than a type 1a supernova. IMAGE: By examining the abundance of the element manganese, a group of astronomers has revised our best estimates for the processes behind supernovae of type Ia. Credit: R. Hurt/Caltech-JPL, Composition: MPIA graphics department. Working with a core of 42 stars within the Milky Way, the team has essentially been reconstructing the evolution of iron and manganese as produced through type Ia supernova explosions. The researchers used iron abundance as an indicator of each star’s age relative to the others; these findings allow them to track the history of manganese in the Milky Way. What they are uncovering is that the ratio of manganese to iron has been constant over the age of our galaxy. The same constant ratio between manganese and iron is found in other galaxies of the Local Group, emerging as what appears to be a universalchemical constant.
This is a result that differs from earlier findings. Previous manganese measurements used the older LTE model, one assuming that stars are perfect spheres, with pressure and gravitational force in equilibrium. Such work helped reinforce the idea that type Ia supernovae most often occurred with a white dwarf drawing material from a giant companion. The data in Bergemann’s work, using Non-LTE models (No Local Thermal Equilibrium), are drawn from ESO’s Very Large Telescope and the Keck Observatory. A different conclusion emerges about how type Ia occurs. The assumption has been that these supernovae happen when a white dwarf orbiting a giant star pulls hydrogen onto its own surface and becomes unstable, having hit the limiting mass discovered by Subrahmanian Chandrasekhar in 1930 (the “Chandrasekhar limit”). This limiting mass means that the total mass of the exploding star is the same from one Type Ia supernova to another, which governs the brightness of the supernova and produces our ‘standard candle.’ The 2011 Nobel Prize in Physics for Saul Perlmutter, Brian Schmidt, and Adam Riess comes out of using Type Ia as distance markers, with readings showing that the expansion of the universe is accelerating, out of which we get ‘dark energy.’ But the work of Bergemann and team shows that other ways to produce a type Ia supernova may better fit the manganese/iron ratio results. These mechanisms may appear the same as the white dwarf/red giant scenario, but because they operate differently, their brightness varies. Two white dwarfs may orbit each other, producing a merger with resulting explosion, or double detonations can occur in some cases as matter accretes onto the white dwarf, with a second explosion in the carbon-oxygen core. In both cases, we are exploring a different scenario than the standard type Ia. The problem: These alternative supernovae scenarios do not necessarily follow the standard candle model. Double detonation explosions do not require a star to reach the Chandrasekhar mass limit. Explosions below this limit will not be as bright as the standard type Ia scenario, meaning the well-defined intrinsic brightness we are looking for in these events is not a reliable measure. _And it appears that the constant ratio of manganese to iron that the researchers have found implies that non-standard type Ia supernovae are not the exception but the rule._ As many as three out of four type 1a supernovae may be ofthis sort.
This is the third paper in a series that is designed to provide observational constraints on the origin of elements and their evolution within the galaxy. The paper notes that the evolution of manganese relative to iron is “a powerful probe of the epoch when SNe Ia started contributing to the chemical enrichment and, therefore, of star formation of the galactic populations.” The models of non-local thermodynamic equilibrium produce a fundamentally different result from earlier modeling and raise questions about the reliability of at least some type Ia measurements to gauge distance. Given existing discrepancies between the Hubble constant as measured by type Ia supernovae and other methods, Bergemann and team have nudged the cosmological consensus in a sensitive place, showing the need to re-examine our standard candles, not all of which may be standard. Upcoming observational data from the gravitational wave detector LISA (due for a launch in the 2030s) may offer a check on the prevalence of white dwarf binaries that could confirm or refute this work. Even sooner, we should have the next data release (DR3) of ESA’s Gaia mission as a valuable reference. The paper is Eitner et al., “Observational constraints on the origin of the elements III. Evidence for the dominant role of sub-Chandrasekhar SN Ia in the chemical evolution of Mn and Fe in the Galaxy,” in press at _Astronomy & Astrophysics_ (preprint).
{ 38 comments
}
VOYAGER AND THE DEEP SPACE NETWORK UPGRADE by Paul Gilster on March 5, 2020 The fault protection routines programmed into Voyager 1 and 2 were designed to protect the spacecraft in the event of unforeseen circumstances. Such an event occurred in late January, when a rotation maneuver planned to calibrate Voyager 2’s onboard magnetic field instrument failed to occur because an unexpected delay in its execution left two systems consuming high levels of power (in Voyager terms) at the same time, overdrawing the available power supply. We looked at this event not long after it happened, and noted that within a couple of days, the Voyager team was able to turn off one of the systems and turn the science instruments back on. Normal operations aboard Voyager 2 were announced on March 3, with five operating science instruments that had been turned off once again returning their data. Such autonomous operation is reassuring because Voyager 2 is now going to lose the ability to receive commands from Earth, owing to upgrades to the Deep Space Network in Australia. This is a temporary situation but one that will last the entire 11 months of the upgrade period. Fortunately, scientists will still be able to receive science data from the craft, which is now 17 billion kilometers from Earth, but they will not be able to send commands to it during this period. The Canberra site is critical to the Voyager interstellar mission because its 70-meter wide antenna is the only one of the three DSN antennae that can communicate with Voyager 2, which is moving relative to the Earth’s orbital plane in such a way that it can only be seen from the southern hemisphere. Thus the California (Goldstone) and Spain (Robledo de Chavela) sites are ruled out, and there is no southern hemisphere antenna other than Canberra’s DSS43 capable of sending S-band signals powerful enough to communicate with Voyager 2. IMAGE: DSS43 is a 70-meter-wide (230-feet-wide) radio antenna at the Deep Space Network’s Canberra facility in Australia. It is the only antenna that can send commands to the Voyager 2 spacecraft. Credit: NASA/Canberra Deep Space Communication Complex. The maintenance at DSS43 is essential, because we have communication and navigation needs for missions like the Mars 2020 rover and future exploration plans for both the Moon and Mars including at some point the crewed missions to the Moon in the Artemis program. Canberra has, in addition to the 70-meter dish, three 34-meter antennae that can receive the Voyager 2 signal, but are unable to transmit commands. During the period in question, Voyager 2 will continue to return data, according to Voyager project manager Suzanne Dodd: > “We put the spacecraft back into a state where it will be just > fine, assuming that everything goes normally with it during the time > that the antenna is down. If things don’t go normally – which is > always a possibility, especially with an aging spacecraft – then > the onboard fault protection that’s there can handle the> situation.”
Expect the work at Canberra to be completed by January of 2021, placing an updated and more reliable antenna back into service and, presumably, continuing the active work managing Voyager 2’s ongoing mission. Better this, engineers reason, than dealing with future unplanned outages as DSS43 ages, while the upgrades will add state-of-the-art technology to the site. Putting all this in perspective is the fact that the dish has been in service for fully 48years.
{ 14 comments
}
CALCULATING LIFE’S POSSIBILITIES ON TITAN by Paul Gilster on March 4, 2020 With surface temperatures around -180° C, Titan presents problems for astrobiology, even if its seasonal rainfall, lakes and seas, and nitrogen-rich atmosphere bear similarities to Earth. Specifically, what kind of cell membrane can form and function in an environment this cold? Five years ago, researchers at Cornell used molecular simulations to screen for the possibilities, suggesting a membrane the scientists called an _azotosome_, which would be made out of the nitrogen, carbon and hydrogen molecules known to exist in Titan’sseas.
The azotosome was a useful construct because the phospholipid bilayer membranes giving rise to liposomes on Earth need an analog that can survive Titan’s conditions, a methane-based membrane that can form in cryogenic temperatures. And the Cornell work suggested that azotosomes would create a similar flexibility to cell membranes found on Earth. Titan’s seas of methane and ethane, then, might offer us the chance for a novel form of life to emerge. Now we have new work out of Chalmers University of Technology in Gothenburg, Sweden that raises serious doubts about whether azotosomes could develop on Titan. The Cornell work examined the liquid organic compound acrylonitrile, found in Titan’s atmosphere, and built the azotosome idea around it, but the Swedish team’s calculations show that azotosomes are unlikely to be able to self-assemble in Titan’s conditions, for the acrylonitrile would crystalize into its molecularice.
Martin Rahm (Department of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Chalmers University of Technology) is co-author of the paper: > “Titan is a fascinating place to test our understanding of the > limits of prebiotic chemistry – the chemistry that precedes life. > What chemical, or possibly biological, structures might form, given > enough time under such different conditions? The suggestion of > azotosomes was a really interesting proposal for an alternative to > cell membranes as we understand them. But our new research paper > shows that, unfortunately, although the structure could indeed > tolerate the extremes of Titan, it would not form in the first> place.”
This is interesting work, and not only because we are on track to launch Dragonfly in 2026, a mission to investigate the surface and sample different locations around the moon in an assessment of prebiotic chemistry. What we’re seeing is the emergence of computational astrobiology, the necessary follow-on to studies like the predictive work of 2015. The idea is to model the properties and formation routes of the materials proposed as supporting possible biological processes. In this case, we learn that the azotosome structure that looked so promising is not thermodynamically feasible. But this work hardly eliminates the possibility of life on Titan. What if, the authors speculate, the cell structure itself is not critical?From the paper:
> …on Titan, any hypothetical life-bearing macromolecule or crucial > machinery of a life form will exist in the solid state and never > risk destruction by dissolution. The question is then whether these > biomolecules would benefit from a cell membrane. Already rendered > immobile by the low temperature, biological macromolecules on Titan > would need to rely on the diffusion of small energetic molecules, > such as H2, C2H2, or HCN, to reach them in order for growth or > replication to ensue. Transport of these molecules might proceed in > the atmosphere or through the surrounding methane/ethane > environment. A membrane would likely hinder this beneficial > diffusion. Similarly, a membrane would likely hinder necessary > removal of waste products of metabolism, such as methane and > nitrogen, in the opposite direction. IMAGE: Researchers looking for life on Titan, Saturn’s largest moon, used quantum mechanical calculations to investigate the viability of azotosomes, a potential form of cell membrane. Credit: NASA / Yen Strandqvist / Chalmers. At this stage, as the authors note, the limits of prebiotic chemistry and biology on Titan will have to stay in the realm of speculation, but computations like these can inform the choice of sites for Dragonfly as it explores the moon, helping us to match the reality on the ground with theory. The paper is Sandström & Rahm, “Can polarity-inverted membranes self-assemble on Titan?” _Science Advances_ Vol. 6, No. 4 (24 January 2020). Full text. The 2015 paper
on azotosomes is Stevenson, Lunine & Clancy, “Membrane alternatives in worlds without oxygen: Creation of an azotosome,” _Science Advances_ Vol. 1, No. 1 (27 February 2015), e1400067 (full text).
{ 26 comments
}
ON FREEMAN DYSON
by Paul Gilster on March 2, 2020 Freeman Dyson’s response to the perplexity of our existence was not purely scientific. A polymath by nature, he responded deeply to art and literature and often framed life’s dilemmas through their lens. Always thinking of himself as a mathematician first, he unified quantum electrodynamics and saw the Nobel Prize go to the three who had formulated, in different ways, its structure, but he would cast himself as the Ben Jonson to Richard Feynman’s Shakespeare, a fact noted by Gregory Benford in his review of Phillip F. Schewe’s recent biography. That would be a typical allusion for a man whose restless intellect chafed at smug over-specialization, something neither he nor Feynman could ever be accused of. Feynman, Julian Schwinger and Shinichiro Tomonaga each came up with ways to describe how electrons and photons interrelate, but it was Dyson, on one of his long cross-continental bus trips, who worked out the equivalence of their theories, giving us QED. He would publish the unifying paper in _Physical Review_ in 1949. A year later, he met Tomonaga at Princeton, describing him in a June 24, 1950 letter to his parents as “a charming man, like so many of the really good ones. He talked with me for three hours with much humour and common sense… I have the impression that he is an exceptionally unselfish person.” Which is exactly the impression I had of Dyson in the one interaction (other than email) I had with him, back in 2003 while I was pulling together material for _Centauri Dreams_ and called the Institute for Advanced Study, his scholarly home since 1953, to schedule an interview. It was a spring day and, unfortunately for my purposes, a loud lawn mower was moving up and down outside Dyson’s window. I was having to shout to be heard, a nuisance, and I had trouble hearing him, but we persisted with much repetition and his good humor. Always associated with Project Orion, the dramatic concept to propel a spacecraft by exploding nuclear charges behind it, Dyson had moved away from the idea, and indeed from nuclear energy entirely. He wanted to talk about microwave and laser propulsion, and expressed an interest in Clifford Singer’s ideas on pellet streams, an idea he liked because of the lack of diffraction. Over a close pass by the outside lawnmower, I heard him clearly: “Nuclear energy doesn’t cut it! Nuclear energy is too small. You’re using less than one percent of the mass with any kind of nuclear reaction so you’re limited to less than a tenth of lightspeed. Nuclear is great inside the Solar System, but not very interesting outside of it.” If you would know something of this man, of his values and his conception of life, I direct you to the splendid _Maker of Patterns: An Autobiography Through Letters_, published in 2018. The concept is daring, for by eschewing standard autobiography to present himself largely through letters he wrote at the time, Dyson gives up the opportunity to edit his persona. None of us can point to a lifetime without contradiction, which is just another way of describing growth. Dyson was willing for that growth to be in full view. Thus the Dyson of 1958, writing about the Project Orion work he would later discount: > The basic idea is absurdly simple. One is amazed that nobody thought > of it before. But the only man who could think of it was somebody > who had been working and thinking for years with bombs, so that he > could know exactly what a bomb of a given size will do. It was not > an accident that this man happened to be Ted . The problem > is to convince oneself that one can sit on top of a bomb without > being fried… Ted’s genius led him to question the obvious > impossibility. For the last six months Ted has spent his time > talking to people in the government and trying to convince them that > this idea is not crazy. He has had a hard time. But it seems we have > now a lot of influential people on our side… Ted and I will fly to > Los Alamos this evening. We travel like Paul and Barnabas. Nothing would come of these travels, of course, because of the signing of the Limited Nuclear Test Ban Treaty of 1963, though Dyson would later support the treaty amid his deep concern over nuclear destruction. The idea of Orion still tantalizes many interstellaradvocates today.
The lack of self-justifying ego — so rare in all too many quarters — that informs Dyson’s writings informs his wide reach into non-scientific markets, where he became the eloquent explainer of concepts he worked with in the course of his long life. I doubt there are many _Centauri Dreams_ readers who do not have at least a few of his titles, books like _Disturbing the Universe_ (1981) and _Infinite in All Directions_ (1988). So many concepts sprang from his insistence on seeing things from a cosmological perspective, including for our interstellar purposes the Dyson sphere and the biological, self-replicating probe called ‘astrochicken’ that was enabled by artificial intelligence. IMAGE: Around the table clockwise are Dyson, Gregory Benford, Jim Benford and David Brin. Taken Jan. 30, 2019, before a discussion between Greg and Dyson at the Clarke Center (available hereon YouTube).
All of these concepts he could relate to the general public through a style that was at once clear and enabling, so that the reader would, like this one, often look up from his or her reading to take in the audacity of ideas that were as logical as they were innovative. The archives of this site are awash with references to Dyson’s contributions, a tribute to his range and his reach. Remarkably, that intellect never deserted him even as his physical strength began to fail. Jim Benford, who has known Dyson since the 1960s, told me on the day of Dyson’s death that he had continued his yearly trips across the country to his La Jolla (CA) residence up until last year. This time around, at 96, he told Jim his doctors had argued against it. He would die a week later, a loss as deep to this field as his contribution was rich. > We shall know what we go to Mars for only after we get there. The > study of whatever forms of life exist on Mars is likely to lead to > better understanding of life in general. This may well be of more > benefit to humanity than irrigating ten Saharas. But that is only > one of many reasons for going. The main purpose is a general > enlargement of human horizons. Thus Dyson in a letter from La Jolla in 1958. Really, you must read _Maker of Patterns_. And from my 2003 interview with him: > Look at how people spread around the Earth. It’s not clear why we > want to travel so much, but we do. It seems to be characteristic of > humans from the time we left Africa. Why do people leave Africa to > spread out to all these desolate places, to Siberia and across the > Pacific? We know that people just do this. It’s part of human> nature…
I think of him foremost as a deeply sane man, one who saw both the aspirations of the human mind as well as its limitations and took on the challenge of explaining life’s mysteries with a fierce joy. No one who reads, and re-reads, his essays and papers can miss this affirmation of mind at work, always building in new directions, unifying, shaping, questioning. It would be superfluous to try to summarize his many accomplishments in one post, for we will, inevitably, be turning his ideas over in our discussions for the rest of the lifetime of _Centauri Dreams_.{ 12 comments
}
Previous Posts
Charter
In _Centauri Dreams_, Paul Gilster looks at peer-reviewed research on deep space exploration, with an eye toward interstellar possibilities. For the last twelve years, this site coordinated its efforts with the Tau Zero Foundation . It now serves as an independent forum for deep space news and ideas. In the logo above, the leftmost star is Alpha Centauri, a triple system closer than any other star, and a primary target for early interstellar probes. To its right is Beta Centauri (not a part of the Alpha Centauri system), with Beta, Gamma, Delta and Epsilon Crucis, stars in the Southern Cross, visible at the far right (image: Marco Lorenzi).
Now Reading
Recent Posts
* Extending the Hunt for Trans-Neptunian Objects * An Unusual Look at Mercury * Exoplanet Climatology: Surprising Find from ESPRESSO * A Rare Brown Dwarf Eclipsing Binary * Where Do ‘Hot Neptunes’ Come From? * WFIRST: Ready for Construction * Cosmic Expansion: A Close Look at a ‘Standard Candle’ * Voyager and the Deep Space Network Upgrade * Calculating Life’s Possibilities on Titan* On Freeman Dyson
On Comments
If you'd like to submit a comment for possible publication on _Centauri Dreams_, I will be glad to consider it. The primary criterion is that comments contribute meaningfully to the debate. Among other criteria for selection: Comments must be on topic, directly related to the post in question, must use appropriate language, and must not be abusive to others. Civility counts. In addition, a valid email address is required for a comment to be considered. _Centauri Dreams_ is emphatically not a soapbox for political or religious views submitted by individuals or organizations. A long form of the policy can be viewed on the Administrative page. The short form is this: If your comment is not on topic and respectful to your fellow readers, I'm probably not going to run it. Enter your email address to receive blog posts from Centauri Dreamsvia email:
Delivered by FeedBurnerSubscribe in a
reader
Advanced Propulsion Research Exoplanet Projects (Earth)* AFOE
* Amateur Exoplanet Archive * Anglo-Australian Planet Search* APACHE Project
* ASTEP: Antarctic Search for Transiting Extrasolar Planets* ASTRA
* Astro Gregas
* Atacama Large Millimetre Array * Automated Planet Finder * Berlin Exoplanet Search Telescope * California & Carnegie Planet Search * Carl Sagan Institute (Cornell)* CARMENES
* Carnegie Astrometric Planet Search * CBA Belgium Observatory* CHIRON
* CODEX
* Colossus
* Coralie
* DayNight
* DEMONEX (DEdicated MONitor of EXotransits) * East Asian Planet Search Network* Elodie
* ESO Coude Echelle Spectrometer * ESPRESSO (Echelle SPectrograph for Rocky Exoplanet and Stable Spectroscopic Observations) * European Extremely Large Telescope* Evryscope
* Exoplanet Tracker
* Externally Dispersed Interferometry* Fabra-ROA
* GAPS (Global Architecture of Planetary Systems) * Gemini Planet Imager * GEMSS: Global Exoplanet M-dwarf Search-Survey * Geneva Extrasolar Planet Search * Habitable Zone Planet Finder* HARPS North
* HARPS-N
* HATNet Exoplanet Survey * High Accuracy Radial velocity Planetary Search * Hobby-Eberly Telescope * Italian Search for Extraterrestrial Life* ITASEL
* Keck Interferometer * Keck Planet Finder* KELT North
* KELT South
* KMTNet (Korea Microlensing Telescope Network) * Large Binocular Telescope * Las Cumbres Global Telescope Network * Low Frequency Array* LYOT Project
* MACHO
* Magdalena Ridge Optical Interferometer * Magellan Telescope* MARVELS
* MARVELS (Multi-object APO Radial Velocity Exoplanet Large-areaSurvey)
* MASCARA
* Maunakea Spectroscopic Explorer * McDonald Observatory* MEarth
* METIS (Mid-Infrared E-ELT Imager and Spectrograph) * MicroFUN MICROLENSING FOLLOW- UP NETWORK * Microlensing Planet Search Project * MINERVA (MINiature Exoplanet Radial Velocity Array)* MOA
* MONET
* N2K
* Nancay Decametric Search* NEAR
* NEID Spectrograph
* New Mexico Exoplanet Spectroscopic Survey Instrument * NGTS (Next-Generation Transit Survey) * Okayama Planet Search Program * Optical Gravitational Lensing Experiment* OWL
* PARAS (PRL Advanced Radial-velocity Allsky Search) * Permanent All Sky Survey* PHASES
* PIRATE (Physics Innovations Robotic Astronomical TelescopeExplorer)
* PISCES (Planets in Stellar Clusters Extensive Search)* PLANET
* PLANETS
* Precision Radial Velocity Spectrometer* PRIMA-DDL
* Project 1640
* Pulsar Planet Detection * QES (Qatar Exoplanet Survey) * Radio Interferometric Planet Search * RoboNet (Microlensing)* SAINT-EX
* Search for Trojan Extrasolar Planets * SEEDS (Subaru Strategic Exploration of Exoplanets and Disks)* SHINE
* Solaris
* Sophie
* Spectrashift
* SPECULOOS
* SPHERE
* SPOTS: (Search for Planets Orbiting Two Stars * Square Kilometer Array* STARE
* STELLA
* SuperWASP
* Systemic
* Tennessee Automatic Photoelectric Telescope* TEP
* Thirty Meter Telescope* TransitSearch
* Transitsearch
* TRAPPIST (TRAnsiting Planets and PlanetesImals Small Telescope) * TrES: The Transatlantic Exoplanet Survey* TRESCA Project
* University of St. Andrews Planet Search* UNSWEPS Project
* UVES
* Very Large Telescope Interferometer* VIDA
* WASP (Wide Angle Search for Planets)* WHAT
* XO Project
Exoplanet Projects (Space)* ACEsat
* Aragoscope
* ARIEL: (Atmospheric Remote-Sensing Infrared ExoplanetLarge-survey)
* ASTERIA
* Astro-1
* ATLAST (Advanced Technology Large-Aperture Space Telescope) * CHEOPS – CHaracterising ExOPlanet Satellite* CoRoT
* CubeSat
* Darwin
* Dual Use Exoplanet Telescope * ECHO (Exoplanet Characterization Observatory)* Eddington
* EPOXI (Extrasolar Planet Observation and Deep Impact ExtendedInvestigation)
* EXCEDE
* ExoplanetSat CubeSat* FINESSE
* Gaia
* GEST
* HabEx
* HEK (Hunt for Exomoons with Kepler) * High Étendue Multiple Object Spectrographic Telescope (THE MOST) * High-Definition Space Telescope* HST Astrometry
* James Webb Space Telescope* Kepler
* Kilometer Space Telescope * Laser Interferometer Space Antenna * LISE Hypertelescope* LUVOIR
* MOST (Microvariability and Oscillations of STars)* NEAT
* New Worlds Imager
* Origins Billion Star Survey * Origins Space Telescope* Pegase
* Planet Imaging Concept Testbed* Plato
* PlaVi (PlanetVision)* Project Blue
* Space Interferometry Mission * SPICES (Spectro-Polarimetric Imaging and Characterization of Exo-planetary Systems) * Spitzer Space Telescope* SUPER-SHARP
* SWEEPS
* Terrestrial Planet Finder * TESS (Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite)* Twinkle
* UMBRAS
* WFIRST (Wide-Field Infrared Survey Telescope) Further Astronomical and Astronautical Resources* 100 Year Starship
* Acta Astronautica
* ADS Abstract Service * Alternative Earths Astrobiology Center * American Astronomical Society * American Geophysical Union * American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics * astro-ph preprint server * AstroArt of David A. Hardy* AstroBetter
* Astrobiology Magazine* Astrobites
* Astrometry.net
* Astronautics Now
* Astronomical Journal * Astronomy & Astrophysics * Astronomy Picture of the Day * Astrophysical Journal * British Interplanetary Society * Bulletin of the American Astronomical Society* Cosmic Ancestry
* Division for Planetary Sciences * European Federation of Biophysics * Event Horizon Telescope * Exoplanet Transit Database * Extrasolar Planets and Astrobiology * Extrasolar Planets Encyclopedia* Galaxy Forum
* Google Scholar
* Icarus Interstellar * Institute for Interstellar Studies * Interstellar Journey* James Benford
* L’Institut de l’Information Scientifique et Technique * Lunar and Planetary Institute * Meteoritics and Planetary Science * NASA Technical Reports Server* Nature
* Overview Institute* Physics
* Planetary and Life Science Community Meetings Calendar * Planetary and Space Science * Principium (Journal of I4IS)* ResearchGATE
* RocketSTEM
* Science
* Scitizen
* SDSS SkyServer
* SETI News
* SFSU Exoplanet Group * SIMBAD Astronomical Database* Space Agenda
* Space Sailing
* Space Telescope Science Institute * Space Transport and Engineering Methods* spaceweather.com
* The neighborhood
Weblogs, Discussions, Commentaries * Adam Crowl (Crowlspace)* Adrian Berry
* Airminded
* Alien Life
* Ancient Solar System* Antimatter
* Apparent Brightness* AstroBlog
* AstroEngine.com
* Astrogator's Logs (Athena Andreadis) * Astronautical Evolution* Astronomist
* Astronomy Blog
* Astronomy.com Blog* astroPT
* Astroquizzical
* Asymptotia
* Atlas of the Universe* B612 Foundation
* Bad Astronomy
* Beyond Earthly Skies* Beyond Impossible
* Billion Year Plan
* Buran Space Shuttle * Captain Interstellar (Paul Titze)* Celestial Matters
* Cheap Astronomy
* Cocktail Party Physics* collectSPACE
* Colony Worlds
* Comets & Asteroids: Small Bodies of the Solar System* Cosmic Diary
* Cosmic Mirror
* Cosmic Tusk
* Cosmic Variance
* Cosmic Visions
* CosmoCoffee
* Cumbrian Sky
* Dad2059
* Deep Sky Blog
* Dialogos of Eide
* Dick’s Rocket Dungeon* Dragon's Gaze
* Dream of the Open Channel * Dreams of Space: Books and Ephemera * Drew Ex Machina (Andrew LePage) * DSFP's Spaceflight History Blog* Dynamics of Cats
* Eternos Aprendizes* Eureka
* Eureka (Daniel Marín)* Ex Space
* ExoClimes.com
* Exoplanetology
* Exoplanets Channel * Exploring the Universe * Extrasolar Visions II* Final Frontier
* Finding Pluto
* Flank Speed
* Fly Me to the Moon* Future & Cosmos
* Future Incredible
* Future Planetary Exploration* Futurismic
* Galactic Journey
* Gregory Benford
* Habitable Worlds
* Habitable Zone
* Hop's Blog
* Il Tredicesimo Cavaliere* Innovation Watch
* Innumerable Worlds* Invitation to ETI
* Isaac Arthur (videos)* James Essig
* James Randi Educational Foundation Forum * John Cleary Creations* Jon Lomberg
* Kentucky Space
* Know the Cosmos
* Last Word on Nothing * Laurel's Pluto Blog * Leonard David's Inside Outer Space* Letters to Nature
* Lifeboat Foundation* Lone Mind
* Long Bets Foundation * Long Now Foundation* Lost in Transits
* Magellan AO
* Many Worlds (Marc Kaufman) * Martian Chronicles* Meridiani Journal
* Music of the Spheres* Nano Age
* NASA Watch
* NASA-UC Eta-Earth Survey* New Papyrus
* Next Big Future
* NGTS (Next-Generation Transit Survey) * On the Path to Space * One-Minute Astronomer* OrbitalHub
* Orion's Arm
* Our Universe in 202 Notations* Out of the Cradle
* Patrick McCray
* peregrinus interstellar * PHASES (Palomar High-precision Astrometric Search for ExoplanetSystems)
* Physics arXiv Blog* PI Club
* Planet/Planet
* PLANETPLANET (Sean Raymond) * Polymath (Robert Clark)* Posthuman Blues
* Potentia Tenebras Repellendi * Profiles of Our Future in Space * Project Icarus Weblog * Project Rho (Winchell Chung)* Quasar9
* Real Science
* Remote Central
* Rick Costello Space Art * Riding with Robots* Robot Explorers
* Robot Guy
* Rymden i Dag
* Science News
* SciTech Journal
* Scitizen
* Simostronomy
* Singularity Institute* Slacker Astronomy
* SolStation
* Sorting Out Science* Space Archaeology
* Space Elevator Blog* Space FTW
* Space Law Probe
* Space Pragmatism
* Space Review
* Space Transport News * Spaceflight History * Spacewriter’s Ramblings * Stan Erickson's Alien Civilization Blog* Star Bright?
* Star Stryder
* Starts with a Bang* Strange Paths
* Sufficiently Advanced * Supernova Condensate * This Is Rocket Science * This Week’s Finds in Mathematical Physics* Tiny Mantras
* Titan Exploration
* Tom Barclay/Planet Hunter* Tomorrow Is Here
* Trevor Paglen
* Ultratech Memes
* Universe Today
* Unmanned Spaceflight * Velcro City Tourist Board* Visions 2200
* Visual Astronomy
* Visualizing Science* Wanderingspace
* Watered Down Physics * Where's The Flux (Tabby's Star)* Will Gater
* Woodward Effect
* Worlds of David Darling * Wow! Signal Podcast* Written Worlds
Archives
* March 2020
* February 2020
* January 2020
* December 2019
* November 2019
* October 2019
* September 2019
* August 2019
* July 2019
* June 2019
* May 2019
* April 2019
* March 2019
* February 2019
* January 2019
* December 2018
* November 2018
* October 2018
* September 2018
* August 2018
* July 2018
* June 2018
* May 2018
* April 2018
* March 2018
* February 2018
* January 2018
* December 2017
* November 2017
* October 2017
* September 2017
* August 2017
* July 2017
* June 2017
* May 2017
* April 2017
* March 2017
* February 2017
* January 2017
* December 2016
* November 2016
* October 2016
* September 2016
* August 2016
* July 2016
* June 2016
* May 2016
* April 2016
* March 2016
* February 2016
* January 2016
* December 2015
* November 2015
* October 2015
* September 2015
* August 2015
* July 2015
* June 2015
* May 2015
* April 2015
* March 2015
* February 2015
* January 2015
* December 2014
* November 2014
* October 2014
* September 2014
* August 2014
* July 2014
* June 2014
* May 2014
* April 2014
* March 2014
* February 2014
* January 2014
* December 2013
* November 2013
* October 2013
* September 2013
* August 2013
* July 2013
* June 2013
* May 2013
* April 2013
* March 2013
* February 2013
* January 2013
* December 2012
* November 2012
* October 2012
* September 2012
* August 2012
* July 2012
* June 2012
* May 2012
* April 2012
* March 2012
* February 2012
* January 2012
* December 2011
* November 2011
* October 2011
* September 2011
* August 2011
* July 2011
* June 2011
* May 2011
* April 2011
* March 2011
* February 2011
* January 2011
* December 2010
* November 2010
* October 2010
* September 2010
* August 2010
* July 2010
* June 2010
* May 2010
* April 2010
* March 2010
* February 2010
* January 2010
* December 2009
* November 2009
* October 2009
* September 2009
* August 2009
* July 2009
* June 2009
* May 2009
* April 2009
* March 2009
* February 2009
* January 2009
* December 2008
* November 2008
* October 2008
* September 2008
* August 2008
* July 2008
* June 2008
* May 2008
* April 2008
* March 2008
* February 2008
* January 2008
* December 2007
* November 2007
* October 2007
* September 2007
* August 2007
* July 2007
* June 2007
* May 2007
* April 2007
* March 2007
* February 2007
* January 2007
* December 2006
* November 2006
* October 2006
* September 2006
* August 2006
* July 2006
* June 2006
* May 2006
* April 2006
* March 2006
* February 2006
* January 2006
* December 2005
* November 2005
* October 2005
* September 2005
* August 2005
* July 2005
* June 2005
* May 2005
* April 2005
* March 2005
* February 2005
* January 2005
* December 2004
* November 2004
* October 2004
* September 2004
* August 2004
Meta
* Log in
* Entries RSS
* Comments RSS
* WordPress.org
This site rocks the Classic Responsive Modded Skin for Thesis.
WP Admin
Details
Copyright © 2024 ArchiveBay.com. All rights reserved. Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | DMCA | 2021 | Feedback | Advertising | RSS 2.0